TikTok Seen Moving Toward U.S. Security Deal, but Hurdles Remain
The Biden administration and TikTok have drafted a preliminary agreement to resolve national security concerns posed by the Chinese-owned video app but facehurdles over the terms, as the platform negotiates to keep operating in the United States without major changes to its ownership structure, four people with knowledge of the discussions said.
The two sides have hammered out the foundations of a deal in which TikTok would make changes to its data security and governance without requiring its owner, the Chinese internet giant ByteDance, to sell it, said three of the people, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because the negotiations are confidential.
The two sides are still wrangling over the potential agreement. The Justice Department is leading the negotiations with TikTok, and its No. 2 official, Lisa Monaco, has concerns that the terms are not tough enough on China, two people with knowledge of the matter said. The Treasury Department, which plays a key role in approving deals involving national security risks, is also skeptical that the potential agreement with TikTok can sufficiently resolve national security issues, two people with knowledge of the matter said. That could force changes to the terms and drag out a final resolution for months.
TikTok, one of the world’s most popular social media apps, has been under a legal cloud in the United States for more than two years because of its Chinese ties. Lawmakers and regulators have repeatedly raised concerns about TikTok’s ability to protect the data of American users from Chinese authorities. President Donald J. Trump tried to force ByteDance to sell TikTok to an American company in 2020 and threatened to block the app.
If completed, an agreement with the Biden administration is likely to be highly scrutinized, as TikTok has become a symbol of the Cold War-like atmosphere in relations between Beijing and Washington. As part of the tit-for-tat, the nations are battling over primacy in technology and digital data. Skepticism toward China is a built-in feature of U.S. politics, and the talks are taking place just weeks before November’s midterm elections.
Completing an agreement may also be difficult at a tricky political moment for the Biden administration, which has stepped up its cadence of criticism and executive actions addressing China. The policy toward Beijing, while expressed in more diplomatic language, is not substantially different from the posture of the Trump White House, reflecting a suspicion of China that now spans the political spectrum. Nevertheless, Republicans have criticized the administration for being too soft on China.
“Anything short of a complete separation” of TikTok from ByteDance “will likely leave significant national security issues regarding operations, data and algorithms unresolved,” Senator Marco Rubio of Florida, the top Republican on the Intelligence Committee, said in a statement.
TikTok has been negotiating with representatives for the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States, or CFIUS, a group of federal agencies that reviews investments by foreign entities in American companies, to resolve concerns that the app puts national security at risk. The group would need to sign off on an agreement, and potentially President Biden as well.
A spokesman for the Treasury Department, which leads the group, said that as a general matter,the committee “is committed to taking all necessary actions within its authority to safeguard U.S. national security.”
TikTok declined to comment on the talks but said it was “confident” that it was “on a path to fully satisfy all reasonable U.S. national security concerns.”
Vanessa Pappas, TikTok’s chief operating officer, told senators this month that the app would “satisfy all national security concerns.”Credit…Haiyun Jiang/The New York Times
At a Senate hearing about social media and national security this month, Vanessa Pappas, TikTok’s chief operating officer, declined to commit to cutting employees in China off from the app’s American data but said any agreement with the government would “satisfy all national security concerns.”
A Justice Department spokeswoman declined to comment, as did a spokeswoman for the White House. ByteDance did not respond to a request for comment.
Tensions over TikTok have mounted for years. After Mr. Trump ordered ByteDance to sell the app or risk being blocked from Apple’s and Google’s app stores in 2020, the Chinese company appeared to reach an agreement to sell part of TikTok to Oracle, the American cloud computing company. But the deal never closed, and a federal court ruled against Mr. Trump’s attempt to block the app.
That left TikTok’s fate in the hands of Mr. Biden. Last year, he issued an order rolling back Mr. Trump’s demand that TikTok be blocked. His administration set out to develop a policy toward the app and others owned by foreign entities.
The Biden administration’s plans for TikTok were thrust back into the spotlight in June when BuzzFeed News reported that the company’s employees in China had access to TikTok’s U.S. data as recently as this year.
Negotiations between CFIUS and TikTok have dragged on as officials wrapped their arms around complex technical questions about the app. They edged closer to a detailedagreement in recent months, two people with knowledge of the discussions said.
Under the draft terms, TikTok would make changes to three main areas, the people with knowledge of the discussions said.
First, TikTok would store its American data solely on servers in the United States, probably run by Oracle, instead of on its own servers in Singapore and Virginia, two of the people said. Second, Oracle is expected to monitor TikTok’s powerful algorithms that determine the content that the app recommends, in response to concerns that the Chinese government could use its feed as a way to influence the American public, they said. Lastly, TikTok would create a board of security experts, reporting to the government, to oversee its U.S. operations, three people with knowledge said.
BuzzFeed earlier reported TikTok’s plan to store its data with Oracle; Axios earlier reported that Oracle had started monitoring TikTok’s algorithms.
TikTok is represented in the negotiations by the law firms Covington & Burling and Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom, people familiar with the matter said. Among the government officials negotiating a deal are Adam Hickey, a Justice Department national security lawyer, two people with knowledge of the talks said.
Oracle is not directly involved in the negotiations but has been consulted by the government, another person said. Oracle declined to comment.
The terms of the draft deal are being reviewed by Ms. Monaco, among others, four people with knowledge of the matter said. A former Obama White House national security official, Ms. Monaco has a reputation for taking a hard line on Beijing, which has, in part, slowed a resolution, these people said.
Within the Biden administration, officials approach how to handle China differently. Treasury Secretary Janet L. Yellen is often viewed as more accommodating and has called for scaling back some U.S. tariffs on Chinese imports because of the burden they place on companies and consumers. Others, such as the national security adviser, Jake Sullivan, have called for the United States to closely scrutinize commercial ties with China.
“President Biden does not seem to be able to decide which side of his administration he wants to back,” said Derek Scissors, a senior fellow at the conservative American Enterprise Institute, citing the administration’s perceived slowness in rolling out executive orders against China.
Mr. Biden told CFIUS in an executive order this month that it should consider whether deals would expose data from the United States to foreign adversaries.
The White House has also been working on two other executive orders to address concerns about China, a person with knowledge of the matter said. One would tackle worries that American investors were putting money into Chinese firms, the person said. U.S. companies have spent roughly $15 billion on deals in China so far this year, compared with $21 billion during the same period last year, according to the data firm Dealogic.
The second executive order could give the government more power to take on apps that — like TikTok — could leak data to a foreign power.
Any resolution on TikTok would also most likely “provide a blueprint” for handling similar cases in the future, said Antonia Tzinova, a partner at the law firm Holland & Knight who specializes in CFIUS and national security. “China is perceived as a threat, and Big Data, or data generally, is of particular concern.”
Kirsten Noyes contributed research.